The Paperless Office Never Happened
For decades, technology was supposed to make paper disappear from the workplace. Xerox PARC was already talking about the “Office of the Future” in the 1970s. Indeed, the phrase “paperless office” became part of the office-automation vocabulary in the late 1970s.
By the 1990s, email, PCs, the web, and document management systems made the paperless office seem increasingly plausible. In Abigail Sellen and Richard Harper’s The Myth of the Paperless Office (2001), the assumption was that people used paper simply because digital technology hadn’t advanced enough. Yet, paper never disappeared.
But why didn’t the paperless office ever happen? What makes paper so essential and indispensable?
Why the paperless office didn’t happen
This is one of the most interesting findings from Sellen & Harper. Email and digital communication didn’t necessarily reduce paperwork. They could actually increase the amount of material people printed and handled. In fact, organizational email was associated with an average 40% increase in paper consumption.
Paper was not just a storage medium. It was portable, easy to mark up, easy to pass around, easy to read side by side, and trusted in situations where a screen or file system felt less convenient. In other words, paper was not only something people wanted to get rid of, but also something that helped them work.
This created an interesting paradox: the tools designed to reduce our dependence on paper also gave us access to much more information. And the more information people received, the more they found reasons to print.
In parallel, even though documents were born digitally more often than not, the real world kept producing paper: receipts, invoices, contracts, IDs, business cards, tickets, etc. The idea was that the paperless office could make digital documents easier to manage, but it couldn’t stop the outside world from handing you pieces of paper.
With the idea of the paperless office, we focused on what happened after a document entered the computer, but we never solved the problem of getting the physical document into the computer in the first place.
The real breakthrough wasn’t the paperless office; it was the smartphone
Once it became clear that paper documents were not going to disappear, the question changed. We stopped asking “how do I get rid of paper” and started asking “what if I could always have my paper documents everywhere with me”.
And the smartphone happened.
By combining communication, navigation, organization, document storage, and internet access in one device, the smartphone replaced a surprising number of standalone tools: cameras, paper maps, calculators, address books, scanners, fax machines, and more.
Pew’s long-running data shows how quickly mobile phones became ubiquitous. By 2009, roughly 85% of U.S. adults owned a cellphone, while smartphones subsequently became the dominant form of mobile phone. And Pew’s 2014 workplace research already described internet access and cell phones as having “infiltrated every cranny” of American workplaces, with digital technology transforming a very broad range of jobs.
Once smartphones could scan and store paper documents anywhere, the very idea of getting rid of paper altogether started to dissipate. The focus shifted to digitizing and sharing paper documents more easily.
However, with time, paper consumption did start falling. Michael Briscoe revisited the paperless-office question in a 2022 academic paper, using United Nations FAO data.
He found that global consumption had levelled off and consumption was declining in most regions. In fact, in the US, paper and paperboard consumption had fallen to about 63 million metric tons, versus 95 million at its peak in 1999 (a decrease of 33.6%).
And to no one’s surprise, Briscoe identifies smartphones and mobile internet as improved “displacement technologies.” He observes that the decline in paper consumption in North America, Europe, and Oceania accelerates around 2007–2010, around the emergence of the modern smartphone.
The timing is striking: after decades in which digital technology coexisted with increasing paper consumption, paper consumption began falling substantially as smartphones and mobile internet became widespread.
From paperless to paper anywhere
Today, the smartphone doesn’t eliminate paper, but it makes the transition between physical and digital much easier.
Before smartphones, our old model was paper > office > scanner > computer > file. With smartphones, it shifted to paper > phone > digital document > wherever it needs to go.
And this is where apps such as Genius Scan fit into the story. The scanner stopped being a place. It became a pocket tool. A smartphone already had a camera, a screen, internet access, and enough computing power to process images. Adding document scanning meant that one of the last pieces of office hardware could move into your pocket.
Now, you can scan a receipt in a restaurant, a contract at a customer’s office, a form at home, a business card after a meeting, or paperwork while travelling.
Not only did the paperless office never happen, but the office itself was reinvented. With the ability to communicate and store data from anywhere, smartphones changed where work could happen.
As early as 2014, the Pew study found that among workers who worked outside their normal workplace at least occasionally:
- 21% did so every day or almost every day;
- another 13% did so a few times a week;
- among those working remotely, half said the internet and cell phones were “very important” to their ability to work remotely;
This data is especially interesting because it predates the COVID pandemic. Mobile technology was already enabling a more distributed workplace long before remote work became widespread.
Then, the pandemic later revealed how much of this infrastructure was already in place.
For years, the infrastructure had been developing: smartphones, laptops, cloud storage, video conferencing, mobile scanning, digital payments, online document management… Then suddenly millions of people couldn’t go to the office.
Research from Stanford and other economists found that by spring 2020, about half of employed Americans were working from home, including 35.2% who had recently switched from commuting to working remotely.
COVID didn’t invent remote work: it revealed how much of the office had already become software. And the smartphone was one of the major pieces that made that possible.
In conclusion, we never built the paperless office exactly as imagined. Instead, we built something stranger and more practical: an officeless office, where paper still exists, but the work of capturing, storing, and sending it fits in a pocket.
We went from “no paper” to “less paper, but paper anywhere”.
